Is ScaleUp better than manual Google Tag Manager setup?

For most Shopify merchants, ScaleUp provides better accuracy (99.9% vs 70-85%), faster setup (5 minutes vs 2-4 hours), and lower total cost of ownership. Manual GTM setup may be preferred if you need highly custom tracking configurations.

How much time does manual Google Ads tracking setup take?

Manual setup typically takes 2-4 hours for initial configuration, plus ongoing maintenance of 1-2 hours monthly to handle platform updates and troubleshoot issues. ScaleUp reduces this to 5 minutes initial setup with zero ongoing maintenance.

What is the accuracy difference between ScaleUp and manual tracking?

ScaleUp achieves 99.9% tracking accuracy using Enhanced Conversions and error prevention. Manual setups typically achieve 70-85% accuracy due to ad blockers, iOS restrictions, and configuration errors that go undetected.

Does ScaleUp work with Google Tag Manager?

ScaleUp works independently and does not require Google Tag Manager. It installs directly as a Shopify app and handles all tracking automatically. If you have existing GTM setup, you should disable duplicate conversion tags to prevent double-counting.

ScaleUp vs Manual Setup

Compare automated conversion tracking with manual Google Tag Manager configuration.

TL;DR: ScaleUp sets up in 5 minutes vs 2-4 hours for manual GTM. You get 99.9% accuracy vs 70-85%, zero maintenance, and it's free. Choose manual only if you need highly custom event tracking.

Feature	ScaleUp	Manual (GTM)
Setup Time	5 minutes	2-4 hours
Technical Skills	None required	GTM, JavaScript, Data Layer
Tracking Accuracy	99.9%	70-85%
Enhanced Conversions	Automatic	Manual setup
Ad Blocker Resistance	Built-in	Not included
Duplicate Prevention	Automatic	Manual logic required
Shopify Updates	Auto-compatible	May break, needs fixes
Maintenance	None	1-2 hours/month
GDPR/Consent Mode	Built-in	Additional setup
Cost	Free	Free (time cost)
Custom Events	Standard e-commerce	Fully customizable

Why the Accuracy Difference?

Manual GTM setups typically achieve 70-85% accuracy due to several factors:

• Ad blockers block GTM tags for 30-40% of users
• iOS privacy limits cookie tracking to 7 days
• Configuration errors often go undetected
• Shopify updates can break manual implementations

ScaleUp achieves 99.9% accuracy by using Enhanced Conversions (first-party data matching), Shopify's Web Pixel API (not blocked by ad blockers), and automatic error detection.

Total Cost of Ownership (1 Year)

ScaleUp

App cost$0

Setup (5 min @ $50/hr)$4

Maintenance$0

Total$4

Manual Setup

GTM cost$0

Setup (3 hrs @ $50/hr)$150

Maintenance (18 hrs @ $50/hr)$900

Total$1,050

Based on average developer/marketer hourly rate of $50.

When Manual Setup Makes Sense

Manual GTM setup may be the right choice if:

• You need custom event tracking beyond standard e-commerce events
• You have a dedicated developer for ongoing maintenance
• You're using GTM for multiple platforms and want unified management
• You need server-side GTM for advanced tracking

Ready to switch?

Get 99.9% accuracy with zero maintenance.

Install Free on Shopify